Home > Video Game Industry > Achievements Are Evil! Or At The Very Least They Change How You Game

Achievements Are Evil! Or At The Very Least They Change How You Game

NFS Most Wanted was my first gamer score victim. 1000 points earned.

It’s hard to remember now, but I believe my very first achievement came in November 2005 while playing Madden 06. Or perhaps it was Need For Speed Most Wanted.  2005 was a long time ago.  I do remember the joy of hearing the pop that meant an increase in gamer score.  Even though I have spent more than five years improving that score, I still get a thrill from hearing that sound.

For those who don’t know, achievements are in-game challenges that can be unlocked by reaching certain milestones. Each one is worth so many points and they are directly tied to your Xbox gamer score. Some of these achievements are quite easy while others require gamers to torture themselves as they tried repeatedly to unlock them.

There was time when I would look for games with easy achievements so that I could get a quick fix. Even now I will work long and hard to earn one just to know that I conquered  a challenge.  However five years of looking at my gamer score have reminded me that games are supposed to be about having fun.  Last night a friend of mine saw my status as playing Mass Effect 1 and asked if I had all the achievements.  (I do.  In fact I have unlocked everything for Mass Effect 1 & 2.) I really didn’t want to take the time to tell him that sometimes I play just for fun.  Yes, I worked for all those points in ME1 and 2, and yes I play NCAA Football 11 every day, but that is because I love those games.

And yet somewhere in the back of my mind, I still want to hear that pop.  So I will try out new modes and play games on the hardest difficulty settings to just increase my score.  I will spend weeks or even months trying to pop every achievement on the list.  I will even go so far as to help others unlock them, even if it means spending all night in a game session.

Something is wrong with me.

There was a time when playing a game meant satisfying that need to have fun.  “Fun” could be beating the game or besting another player online. However when Microsoft (and later Sony) added achievements (trophies) to the game space something changed: the objectives.  No longer did I set the difficulty based on how challenging I wanted the game to be.  Now I had to make sure playing on normal or hard or insane or legendary unlocked “chievos” or it was all for nothing. There was now a reason to explore nooks and crannies during single player games because finding all or even half the collectables would bring achievement glory. So I would scour each level to increase my gamer score by ten or fifteen points.  I would find online guides to help secure every piece of intelligence sitting on table or under a tree in Modern Warfare 2.  And once that achievement popped, I could brag to my friends who didn’t have it that I was a master at exploration.

Blast you, Microsoft!

I’m at the point where I have to look at the achievement list before I start to play a game. Worse, I check it often to make sure I am not missing out on any.  And if I do miss some, I will go back and replay a chapter or even an entire game just to get 50 more points.  I’m not strong enough to ignore achievements.  They call to me from the other side of the television screen.

This announcement turned my gaming world upside down.

In doing this Microsoft and Sony not only fill a need in my gaming soul, but they actually create the need that they now seek to fill. Evil. Pure evil. My gaming habits are now forever and irrevocably altered to play the game as they see fit. For the “honor” of bragging to friends and comparing gamer scores, I have molded my game play to make sure I max all the classes in Bad Company 2 (achievement unlocked!), complete Halo Reach on legendary (achievement unlocked!), and find every single novel page in Alan Wake (2 achievements unlocked!).

Brilliant idea Microsoft. Evil, but brilliant.

Categories: Video Game Industry
  1. February 16, 2011 at 23:31

    I’m going to use a terribly overused three-letter word to describe my attitude towards achievements: meh. (Don’t get me started on Sony’s worthless Trophies either.)

    I briefly found myself in the grip of achievement lust, but I’ve mostly avoided it. I like them in the sense they offer a relatively easy (at a glance) way of tracking your progress in the game but I don’t purposely go at a game to get *this* achievement.

    Personally, I prefer the Steam method. Yes, it has achievements as well, but rather because it keeps a running counter of how long I’ve spent playing a given game. When I’ve last played it. Reminding me that Amnesia is pouting in the corner because I haven’t played it in three weeks.

    I may have made that last one up.

  2. Perfectly Flawed
    June 20, 2011 at 08:24

    Agree with you 100%… 🙂 … Achievements have changed the way I game… I used to game for the fun of it.. but now… I too need to check the achievement guide… play the game on the hardest difficulty and scour levels for those hated collectibles… just for the sweet sound of ‘achievement unlocked’…

    But I’m beginning to tone down my achievement hunting… At least to a degree… not chasing achievements where hours of online play are required… I’m just content now with getting the achievements that are part of the story and single player campaign… 😛 …

    In my case, I’m an achievement hunter not for bragging rights.. but just because I can’t bear to look back at a game and it’s achievement list and see something that I could have done over the course of the game.. that I didnt…

    On the positive side.. I think achievements do add a degree of replayability to story-based games.. where once you know the story you’re not inclined to go through it again…

    But achievement hunting or achievement addiction really has a negative impact on ‘how’ you play the game.. sometimes the story blurs by and intense moments are missed as you are too busy figuring out which is the second cupboard in the second house on the third right of the 4th set of stairs you climb for a stupid collectible… :p

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: